This page puts down my thoughts on the subject. Created 23rd November 2019.
On 21st April, 2025, I have added at the end, before "Interesting Articles" an update about the UK Supreme Courts decision made on the 16th April 2025.
Self ID, gender and sexual identities is a controversial subject to many on both sides of the fence but this page finally came to being when on the 23rd November 2019. I came across an article Claimants Witness Statement by Maya Forstater. Statement not now available online. She lost her job as researcher because she started tweeting and blogs about this subject saying biological men should not self identify as women to access women's activities and designated areas. I had recently been reading about men self identifying as women competing in female sports winning, getting trophies for sports person of the year which does not sit with me. Maya's Witness Statement albeit very long covers this topic well, is very clear, well set out and very factual. It is not biased, but even handed and refers to women as well as men on this subject. Also in early November of 2019 I came across this Good Morning Britain on ITV short clip on Gender Identity when articles and tweets about biological men now identifying as women can now enter women's sporting events, winning as well as obtaining sports person of the year awards as a woman. They were biologically still male with all the male attributes.
My View on Gender Identity & Sexual Identity.
I question these modern identities as stand alone descriptions. There are just too many, covering every slight variation. Even I on a few occasions have been asked "so, what do you identify as then?" My standard reply is "the man who prefers skirts just like women who prefer trousers and other male style clothing". Society is obsessed with labels, covered elsewhere on this site, and the more labels created the more is made that an individual is different and society cannot cope with being different to what it perceives as normal. Why not be content with ourselves being as individuals. So what if a man speaks and behaves in a feminine way, as too women who do so in a masculine way. So what if a man or a woman prefers the same sex. So what if a mans appearance is feminine with regards wigs, make up, jewellery, likewise for women's appearance looking and behaving like men. So what if men like me prefer the female clothing wardrobe, after all women openly invade the male wardrobe and do so without questions, labels and identity at them. For me nature creates humans with two biological sexes. Either Male or Female.
The human body is a complex entity, thousands upon thousands of cells, DNA etc anything can get cross wired in its making. I firmly believe this can make males and females to have preferences, emotions and other characteristics that society is so obsessed to attach labels too and specify a gender these labels belong to. We are all at conception female and only the activation of a particular cell at a certain stage of development, at random, does the cell either create testicles and large amounts of Testosterone, i.e. male or Ovaries and Estrogen, i.e. female. I can therefore understand to being attracted to your opposite sex, same sex for the same complexity of the human creation. As a consequence I can accept there is a spectrum for some in society within the society gender label and expectation. On the whole the human body is for the majority is "normal" but as I say the DNA, number of cells can get mixed hence the reason why some humans are born with organs of the opposite sex (Intersex), have disfigurements even faulty parts due to genetics discovered either early or much later in life. Why cannot the personality, feelings and emotions of the person which are unique to us all not get crossed and mixed up, some women can have strong dose of XX chromosome and the male XY chromosome perhaps a weaker Y. As humans, society needs to live by labels, expectation, specific boxes of expectations etc. Any one deviating from slightly to massively does not conform to these specific human labels and boxes and therefore is different and society struggles with differences. Many cannot cope. As I say else where on this site they mock the afflictions of others but fail to see the absurdity of their own. Perhaps this is why some create labels to suit themselves. At the end of the day, regardless of gender spectrum/identity and sexual identity nature still only has two base sexes, male or female and society needs to accept this and live with this and just accept all are unique individuals as man or woman, some with specific characteristics that do not conform to society obsession of binary gender labels. Society is quite free to accept the female variations, but not so for men. I have read about the Gene called the Explorer Gene. DRD47R is the genetic code. DRD4 is standard in us all, it is the personality side of us but 7R is known to be in mountaineers, adventurers, risk takers. Only a few have 7R, the rest have a differing two character code which is what groups our personalities similar to others. I am sure this also affects the gender spectrum and sexual identify as being human we all need to fit to a label, a box, a category. Human society only works by labels, boxes and categories.
This Self Identifying Gender I am not with. Sorry but you cannot be a man, biologically with male strength, emotions, feelings and bits and say you are now a woman therefore you will enter female sports, female designated areas etc and society has to accept without question. Like wise similarly for women self identifying as a men.
Biologically we are either male or female, man or woman. Intersex, people born either male or female but have genitals, chromosomes or reproductive organs of each biological sex, due to the construction by nature, are clearly an exception and most have surgery to correct but are still identified as either male or female. A true Transgender is a person who strongly believes they are in the wrong body and have the necessary operations and drugs that physically transforms their biological makeup, this includes their feelings, emotions and biological sentiment. I understand a true Transgender person who under goes this treatment process that it is complex and painful, involving major surgery and biological tendencies are greatly altered as a consequence. I can understand a person trapped in the wrong body, the making of the human body is complex and can get mixed up. However, despite the surgery and hormone treatment, the body originally created was male or female and I am not sure it can be a full 100% conversion, a high percentage, very high but 100% I have doubts. I do think people who have the surgery and hormone treatment should not be ignored, ridiculed etc, but I do not think they can also claim to be legally women or men and expect access to specific male and female spaces and activities. With regards true Transgender I strongly believe that prior to the age of 18 I do not think Transgender operations should take place, but that is just my perception. By all means engage in discussion if the child talks about being in the wrong body and if it is clearly obvious the child's mind is adamant. For me, I think one needs to be sure before making a very fundamental change. Until Secondary School age the human body is very much evolving, learning, growing and can be confused. There is a distinct difference in children when they start at secondary and such conversations will at that stage of life be far more genuine. Such Transgender change is quite a dramatic move, one that should only be taken when their mind can fully compute and comprehend their feelings. Young human emotions and feelings change wildly with many in their child years. I have no doubts that I am not Transgender or even Gender Self ID but my thoughts and determination as an adult to wear the choice of clothing I do is unquestionable but would I do it publicly aged 8 or 10, even 15? I didn't when I was a child even though since the age of 7 the preference for skirts, more colourful and characterful clothing with personality compared to the set male clothing was my preference. I didn't because at that time, late 60's into 70's society certainly was not understanding and also was it just a phase I was going through as my mind, emotions, feelings developed. It didn't but the rest is covered on my page "Me and Be Yourself Message". School days can be very cruel by others, adult life can be hard but as a person in adult life you are in a different frame of mind. It is the same for children who accept their biological sex but not society constructs. For me this should be embraced but noting the bullying effect at schools. Even in the current era I would not have worn skirts publicly below the age of 18. By that age you are clearly able to formulate decisions and stand up for your self. Skirt wearing as a man, if my time was repeated, I would start from 18 without doubt based upon what I know now, not go public at the age of 48 as I did.
Should Gender & Sexual Identities even breaking of social constructs be taught at school. This is again a very controversial question. I think not as a specific subject over many hours but yes, discuss the breaking of gender stereotypes for women but not for men. This society behaviour creates an imbalance and yes resentment, so why for women but not for men. The discussion should not confuse children even inadvertently brainwash them but they all have access to TV's and the internet and the subject on there. The discussion should be along my paragraph above about the complexity of the human body and we are all different in varying degrees. Knowledge to encourage respect, tolerance, understanding not the negative overtones society is so keen on. Positive is far better than negative. Primary Schools are there in my view for the basic learning of reading and writing with the basics of other subjects. Secondary is when the human mind has really developed and subjects become more thorough. The vast majority of standard human beings, well into the top 90% are all of the standard human expectation. For true Transgender one must accept that persons decision based upon his or her feelings. Mental Health is at stake here and it did affect mine in my early to mid adult years. With regards Self ID, sorry, you are still either your male or female biological sex unless you have undergone true Transgender medial and surgery treatment. For me it is male, female, breaking the society gender stereotypes which are only social constructs as either male or female but you are born male or female. A true Transgender person is a third gender, its like Olympics: male, female and Paralympics.
I am all for society gender social constructs to be dropped for all, not just for the female sex. Let children dress as they want, role play as they want, let boys and girls play with any toy and activity. Girls and boys should be encouraged to play together. It was when I was at primary and I recall pictures of boys and girls being on toy packaging for many if not majority of toys. Girls and boys should know each can achieve whatever, provided they have the knowledge and ability. This should also be possible as adults and for me and all that I know in my life, it does not change you from your nature given biological sex of either man or woman. As I say on this site if clothing choice does change a persons sex for society then why is it only for men but never for women including appearance and behaviour?
I have been aware of the modern increasing labels of gender identity. However this self identification when men who are biologically men are now entering women's sports, toilets, designated changing rooms be it swimming, gym even fitting rooms in shops is beyond common sense for me and I understand for many others. Many organisations in 2019 are now offering such facilities and main political parties were promising in the next UK Parliament as stated in their campaigns of Nov/Dec 2019 election from 2020 to bring Self ID in. For me, Self ID will only cause serious issues. Yes there are some genuine men and women around with Self ID but we all know human society is not and has never been a level playing field and many, and I have to say it will be men mostly, will take advantage of this due to their uncontrolled sexual feelings and emotions. Some of the gender identity labels, and I am not going to list them, but they are so varied to suit whatever a person desires is incredible and some implying you are not man or woman. This debate has increased intensely during the 6 week General Election campaign of 2024 with Labour promising more open Self ID opportunities the Conservatives not. The conservatives have been criticised for not being specific before, and Labour representatives giving mixed responses, either pro, against or as regards its leader very, very vague with replies. Reform, they will just ban Gender Self ID. Whatever, 5 years on this debate is greatly debated and becoming more polarised with many examples of biological males winning in female sports, self ID trans women raping female prisoners, trans women behaving inappropriately in toilets, changing facilities and in June 2024 4 NHS Nurses taking the NHS to Court as a trans woman allowed to use their changing facilities stands and watches women changing into NHS work clothes. For me this has to stop. In 2025 UK Police Forces are allowing biological males with a Gender Recognition Certificate as female attend female strip searches. GDR people have not under gone any hormone or surgery, they must therefore still be male or female as nature made them originally.
I strongly believe a modern society should have freedom, dress as you want, appear as you want, do what you want so long as no physical or psychological harm to others but you are still a man or woman despite what ever gender identity label you want to have or create. It is the same with your biological sex. I also believe in this freedom you should have a minimum of respect offered to you, not be subject to bullying, ridicule or question, you are you and have as much to be you as the next person or those that question you. At the end of the day though biology states you are still either a man or a woman, that is binary but your personality, preferences, are not binary. Society is very obsessed with binary, conforming, fitting in and forces the creation of these multiple gender and sex identities and I don't think it is helping with the realisation that the core principle of humans for sex is male or female regardless of whatever label is created to suit an identity one wants to adopt. Society needs to remember that the majority of society work on male or female and Self ID causes concerns when mixed biological sexes are competing in sport, even areas designated as privacy for people. Society must also weigh up the mental health concerns of individuals who are truly concerned about identities. Negativity does not help, neither is allowing Self ID without thought of others either.
I object to the word cis now being assigned to men and women who accept their birth biological sex. This word has been created to accommodate those who are Transman or Transwoman so they can be called man or woman. We are all either man or woman as I state above. If they need to have this label differentiation then have a 'cis' word for them.
For me I am happy as me, a biological male, whose interests and character spans both male and female society gender constructs and ignores others due to not being interested. I am a human being with the usual human failings, likes, dislikes but an individual true to himself and not curtailed to society male constructs and expectations. The last 2 characters of my DRD4 obviously takes my personality spectrum to include society considered male and female characteristics, clothing society is obsessed as women's only but any wear for women.
Many will see this page as Transphobic. You are always criticised for what ever you do, but these same people do not see what they accuse others of, they are doing the same themselves. That is why I believe in Egalitarian, everyone is a human being, all entitled to freedom, equality and opportunities but at the end of the day we are all human, one can produce sperm, the other can carry the child but we are all otherwise just a human being.
And if you are still reading I will add another controversial reason. My perception only, but I do feel that society, particularly Feminism, have some blame to take here. It is really since the 1990's that women's freedoms, individuality and choice was embraced full on by society, and do not get me wrong, I say this elsewhere on this site, and rightly so. I recall even in the 80's with women's rights being pushed society still had a strict expectation of both men and women as to appearance and behaviour. Many will disagree or state it was only women restricted. That is some 40 years ago so many will not have experienced it. I as a man started work in 1981 and I recall clearly work ethos towards me as a man and also when at school. Similar ethos were placed upon women as well I accept and I also accept society certainly pre 1990's did have restrictions upon women. However, society has stopped all of that, some women will disagree, but still confines men to strict codes of expectations. I mentioned on this site, in 1974 Scouts was made available to girls as well. Over the decades all male institutions have been opened to women, yes one or two are holding out, yet Girl Guides, WI to name but two are still female only. Society accepts women's clothing, appearance, behaviour and what they want to do as individuals, yet still holds men to strict expectations. Is there no wonder that some men who clearly have a mix of X & Y chromosomes away from the standard XX & XY balance look for labels and boxes to assign themselves because society is still obsessed with labels, categories, boxes etc to assign people. True Transgender has been around for many many decades, trans women and trans men in the modern form has only really been since 2000, gaining traction to a point Self ID is now becoming expected. Now I am not excusing some trans women's behaviour of rape, assault, sports, gaining access to female only spaces, that is clearly wrong, should be dealt with but as with all aspects of life there are some genuine ones who need to find a label they can associate with and comply with the society dictate of what do you identify as. A woman is still a woman regardless of appearance, behaviour and choice these days, yet a man can only be a man if he remains in societies fixed expectations, any slight deviation then he cannot be a man. Just an observation of mine.
UK Supreme Court Decision: April 2025
In April 2025 the UK Supreme Court upheld and appeal and stated that under the Equality Act of 2010 and the Gender Recognition Act of 2004, there are only two biological sexes, Man, Woman. Only those born as male or female can claim the rights of male and female. Therefore female spaces, sports etc are for biological females. The same for biological males. I fully agree with this decision. It is common sense. It can only be. However, as I have said above, the human body can get crossed. Within days arguments over the Supreme Court decision rage and some organisations as well as those who want to self identify are to continue as they are. The authorities need to make a stand and uphold the Supreme Courts clarification. Political parties need to make a common sense policy not try to appease all voters and not alienate other voters. They need to lead by example, sadly in the UK from my perception, no political party can do that. However, society as a whole also needs to implement true equality uniformly and across the board. Stop this one sided expectations that it does for both men and women. Accept and respect others freedom of choice, expression and individuality as it does in many areas when it suits. Yes, as a society we need rules and expectation for a society to function, on this topic strict biology. Its like driving on the roads, in the UK we drive on the left hand side, and I cannot drive on the right hand side just because it suits me. Society is at fault with this gender ID fiasco and mainly because it offers full freedom of choice, expression and individuality to women but not for men. It insists on female only spaces but all male spaces have to be open to women. Society needs to look at itself. It needs to help those who think they are the opposite biological sex, have good support to help that person acknowledge and live as the biological sex they are. Society needs to acknowledge that some people need its support and respect as well. Society is very bigoted, hypocritical and nasty. I fully acknowledge that some males do exploit this gender self ID for their own sexual pleasures in an anti society behaviour. This is one reason why I think the UK Supreme Courts decision is correct. The other is affording what should be automatic, recognition to the female sex, the male sex and the distinct differences between the two. I cannot believe successive UK Conservative and Labour Governments have allowed this to evolve.
Interesting articles
https://arcdigital.media/harry-potter-and-the-transgender-revolution-926ad6519451 26th December 2019 - Not online now.
I Knew From the Age of 3 That I Had a Boys Brain but a Girls Body 15th December 2019
https://www.spectator.co.uk/2019/12/trans-activists-are-making-life-harder-for-trans-people/amp/?__twitter_impression=true 14th December 2019 - Not online now.
A new study sheds light on gender identity in children 22nd November 2019
Poll Reveals Gulf in Attitudes Towards Gender Identity Across Great Britain 22nd November 2019